Resources / Manage it yourself, or hire
Should I manage my rental myself or hire a manager?
Self-managing can work if you live close, can answer calls at any hour and are ready to follow Washington's landlord-tenant rules yourself. A manager usually makes more sense when you live far away, own several homes or cannot spare the hours.
II In short
Key points
- 1The deciding factors are the hours you can give each month, how long your home sits vacant, and what one legal mistake would cost you.
- 2Self-managing has no management fee. Our cost guide shows what a manager costs.
- 3Owning a rental is an investment. Managing it is a job. Decide the two separately.
- 4A landlord's legal duties are real and keep changing. The exact wording of required notices, and how they must be served, is where self-managing owners most often get hurt.
- 5Self-managing is reasonable if you live close, answer calls at any hour, and keep up with the rules.
- 6If you self-manage, we can still help you get the home rent-ready.
III The job
What is the job, really?
Managing a rental is nine pieces of work. Add up your own hours for each one before you decide. These nine pieces are the work Welcome Home Properties does for 470+ homes in Walla Walla and College Place.
-
photos, listings, showings and pricing until a lease is signed.
-
income, rental history, credit, background and eviction checks, applied the same way to every applicant.
-
cleaning, repairs, safety checks and vendor scheduling between residents.
-
move-in, during the tenancy and move-out, with written condition records.
-
reminders, late rent, and the notices that come with it.
-
sorting emergencies from routine requests, finding vendors and paying them.
-
ledgers, owner statements and year-end tax documents.
-
holding them, documenting condition, and sending the statement on time.
-
notices, court filings and re-securing the home, if it ever comes to that.
Use the vacancy loss calculator to see what each vacant day costs, and the ROI calculator to compare your own numbers.
IV Investment and job
The investment and the job are two different things
A rental is an investment. Managing it is a job. The investment does not require you to take the job, and the owners who struggle most over the years are usually the ones who never separated the two.
Many of them are glad when they finally sell, because the house took every spare weekend and holiday. But the investment never asked for those weekends. They chose to do the painting, the repairs and the late-night calls themselves. Often it was work they did not enjoy, were not especially suited to, and were paid less for than their own profession pays them.
Here is a simple test. Would you paint a neighbor's house on your weekends for what a painter charges? If not, painting your own rental makes no more sense. The money is exactly the same.
So make two decisions, not one. First, is the house a good investment? Second, which of its jobs do you actually want? Some owners enjoy the work and are good at it, and for them self-managing is a fair choice. If you do not want the job, the investment can still be worth keeping. Miles has written more about this in A rental is an investment. Managing it is a job.
V Side by side
How do the two choices compare?
| Topic | Managing it yourself | Hiring a manager |
|---|---|---|
| Your time | You do every piece of the job, or pay someone for each piece. Calls can come at any hour. | The manager does the work. You read statements and approve larger repairs. |
| Cost | No management fee. You pay vendors, and your own time has a value. | A management fee and, on each new lease, a placement fee. See the cost guide for ours. |
| Leasing and vacancy | You market, show, screen and sign. Every vacant day is a day without rent. | The manager markets, screens and signs the lease. With us, no management fee is charged in a month when no rent is collected. |
| Washington's rules | You carry every duty in the law notes below, and you keep up as the rules change. | The manager handles notices, deposits and screening. With us, the optional guarantee add-on includes a legal compliance guarantee. |
| Repairs and vendors | You find, schedule and pay each vendor. | The manager triages requests and uses its vendor network. With us, invoices pass through at cost and you hear from us before work over the approval amount in your agreement. |
| Records | You keep the ledger, the receipts and the tax records. | Monthly statements, an owner portal, and year-end tax documents. |
| Distance | You need someone close for lockouts, leaks and showings. | A manager based near the home can handle lockouts, leaks and showings. Our office is at 320 N Colville St in Walla Walla. |
VI Legal duties
What legal duties do you carry when you self-manage?
A self-managing owner is the landlord and carries every duty Washington's Residential Landlord-Tenant Act gives a landlord. These are the topics and the statutes. Read them, and ask an attorney about your own situation.
Washington has become demanding about compliance. What usually gets a self-managing owner into trouble is not bad intent. It is the detail: the exact wording a legal notice requires, and the manner in which it has to be served.
-
Washington law Rent increases, the notice and the form: RCW 59.18.700, RCW 59.18.710, RCW 59.18.720, RCW 59.18.140, and the Department of Commerce landlord page.
-
Washington law Entering a rented home: RCW 59.18.150. Ending a tenancy, the notices and how they are served: RCW 59.18.650, RCW 59.18.057, RCW 59.12.040.
-
Washington law The move-in checklist, the deposit trust account and the statement after move-out: RCW 59.18.260, RCW 59.18.270, RCW 59.18.280.
-
Washington law Screening applicants, source of income and discrimination: RCW 59.18.257, RCW 59.18.255, RCW 49.60.222.
-
Washington law Prohibited lease terms and required disclosures: RCW 59.18.230, RCW 59.18.060.
Washington law changes frequently. For the homes we manage, we monitor those changes and adjust our practices. Our legal compliance page describes how.
VII When it fits
When is self-managing a reasonable choice?
Check each statement honestly.
- I live close enough to reach the home quickly when something goes wrong.
- I can answer calls and messages from residents and vendors at any hour, including weekends.
- I have read the Washington rules on rent increases, notices, deposits and screening, and I will check them again every year.
- I use a written lease that follows current Washington law, and I know which lease terms are now prohibited.
- I screen every applicant against the same written criteria and give the required notices.
- I keep a record of every rent payment, deposit and repair.
- I can afford a few vacant months.
- I have reliable plumbers and electricians, and a plan for an emergency at night.
If you can check all or nearly all of these, self-managing is a reasonable choice. If two or more are a no, a manager may fit you better.
VIII Time to switch
What are the signs it is time to switch?
- You have moved away from the home, or bought more homes.
- You have missed a notice or a deadline, or you are not sure you got one right.
- The home has been vacant longer than you planned.
- You dread the calls, or a resident problem is taking more time than you have.
If this sounds familiar, read how to hand over a home with a resident in place. It applies to self-managing owners too.
IX Asked often
Common questions
-
Go through the nine pieces of the work listed above and add up your own hours for each. The total depends on your homes and your residents.
-
The same duties as any landlord, including the rules on rent increases, notices, deposits, screening and lease terms. The law notes above give examples, not a complete list. An attorney can advise on your situation.
-
Yes, with the rent-ready work before you list. We will also line up yard work, painters and gutter crews and oversee the work.
-
You can hand over a home with a resident in place. The resident does not have to move. See the hand-over guide under related pages.
Talk to us
Want to talk it through?
Call us at (509) 525-1040, Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM, or visit 320 N Colville St, Walla Walla.
Schedule Time with Miles Or request a free rental analysis.
