(509) 525‑1040 Free Rental Analysis

Resources  /  Choosing a manager

How to choose a property manager in Walla Walla

A fee sheet will not tell you how your home will be looked after. Four things will, and you can check all four before you sign: how quickly and how well a manager responds, the condition of the homes they already manage, how they present a vacant home to renters, and whether they can explain why they run things the way they do.

  1. 1Test their responsiveness yourself, first as a renter and then as an owner.
  2. 2Look at the homes they manage now. Their listings and a short drive show you how they keep them.
  3. 3See where their vacant homes are advertised, and how well they are presented.
  4. 4Ask what they do, then ask why, and what result they are after. The second and third answers are the ones that matter.
  5. 5The license and the fees are quick to check. Check them, but do not stop there.

III   Responsiveness

1. How responsive are they?

Almost everything an owner cares about runs through how a manager responds. A renter whose question sits unanswered rents somewhere else, and you pay for it in vacant weeks. A resident who reports a slow drip and hears nothing stops reporting, and the next thing anyone hears about is the ceiling. An owner who cannot get a straight answer cannot make a decision about their own property.

    • Be a renter first. Pick one of their listed homes and ask about it the way a renter would. Call during the day. Send a message through the listing in the evening. Note how long a real answer takes, and whether it answers what you asked.
    • Then call as an owner. Do you get an answer, or a clear time when you will? Does the call come when they said it would?
    • Ask about the middle of the night. How does a resident report a burst pipe at 2 a.m., who decides what counts as an emergency, and who actually goes to the house?
    • Ask how you would hear about a problem at your own home. Who tells you, how soon, and with how much detail?
  • Responsiveness is a system, not a personality. Ask who covers when the person you are talking to is out sick. Ask whether requests are logged where the whole office can see them, or whether they live in one person's inbox. A firm that depends on one helpful person is one resignation away from being unresponsive.

    Fast is also not the same as useful. "We will look into it" is a reply, not a response. What you want is an answer, or a next step with a time attached, and then to see it happen.

    Keep in mind that a manager trying to win your business is on their best behavior. If they are slow now, they will not get faster after you sign.

    Our office number is (509) 525-1040, and every home we have available is listed on our rentals page. How we handle repair requests and emergencies is on our maintenance page.

IV   Upkeep

2. How do they keep the homes they already manage?

You do not have to take a manager's word for how they look after property. Their work is public. Every home they have for rent is advertised with photographs and an address.

    • Read all of their current listings, not only the best one. Look at what the photographs show. Is the home clean, or just tidied for the camera? What shape are the paint, floors and yard in? Were the small repairs done before the pictures were taken?
    • Drive past a few of the addresses. Gutters, trash, peeling trim and broken blinds are things a manager sees on every visit and either deals with or does not.
    • Ask about a recent turnover. What did they find when the last resident left, what did they do before the home was listed again, and why?
  • A manager does not own the homes. The owner decides how much to put into a property, and some owners will not spend on anything that is not broken. A dated kitchen or worn carpet usually tells you about the owner's budget, not the manager's standards. No manager's portfolio is a pure reflection of the manager.

    So separate what money decides from what care decides. Finishes, age and upgrades are the owner's call. Cleanliness, working fixtures, a repair done properly instead of patched, and a home that is ready on the day it is listed are the manager's. A modest home can still be clean, sound and well kept.

    Then look at the best homes they manage. Do owners with well-finished, well-maintained properties trust this manager with them, and do those homes still look that way? That tells you whether the manager can take care of nice things. If every home in the portfolio looks tired, either the manager is not recommending the upkeep or owners are not listening. Neither is good for you.

  • A rental is an asset that someone is living in. What protects its value is unglamorous: small repairs made before they become large ones, a standard the home is returned to between residents, and residents who were chosen and treated well enough to look after the place. Rent follows condition, and so does the kind of applicant a home attracts. A manager who lets condition slide is spending your equity to save effort.

    The homes we manage that are available right now are on our rentals page. Look through them. Our rent-ready checklist is the standard we work to before a home is listed.

V   Marketing

3. How do they market a vacant home?

A vacant home earns nothing, and a vacant week is rent you never get back. Marketing is the part of a manager's job aimed straight at that, so look at how well they actually do it.

    • Look at their listings the way a renter does, on a phone. Are the photographs bright, complete and recent? Is there a video? Does the listing answer what every renter asks (the rent, pets, laundry, parking, utilities, when it is available), or does it make them call to find out?
    • Search for one of their homes by its address. Does it appear on the large rental sites renters actually use, as well as on the manager's own site? Are the details the same everywhere? A home that appears only on the manager's website is being shown to a fraction of the people looking.
    • Try to take the next step. Can you ask a question, request a showing and start an application online, at any hour? Every extra step loses applicants.
    • Look for stale listings. Homes advertised as available that turn out to be rented, or a home that has sat for weeks with nothing changed, tell you nobody is watching.
  • Ask how they set the rent, and what they do when a home has not rented. A thoughtful answer talks about comparable homes and the time of year, and it comes with a plan: when they adjust the price, when they change the photographs or the description, and what they tell you along the way. "We are waiting for the right tenant" is not a plan.

    Ask what happens to an inquiry after it arrives. Reach matters, but the goal is not the largest number of inquiries. It is enough qualified applicants that the manager has a real choice. Listing everywhere, answering quickly and making it easy to apply are what create that choice.

    Presentation also sets expectations. A home shown accurately and at its best attracts people who want that home and will care for it. A careless listing attracts careless interest.

    Our listings are on our rentals page, each with its full set of photographs. How we market and lease a home is on our marketing and leasing page.

VI   The business

4. How do they run the business, and why?

Any manager can tell you what they do, and most will give you the same list: screening, rent collection, maintenance, inspections, statements. The list tells you very little. What separates managers is whether they can tell you why they do each thing the way they do, and what result they are trying to produce.

So ask three questions about every part of the job. What do you do? Why do you do it that way? What is it meant to achieve?

  • Listen for: criteria that are written down and applied the same way to every applicant, with a reason for each one that comes from how tenancies actually turn out. The aim is not the fastest approval. It is a resident who pays, stays and looks after the home.

  • Listen for: evidence rather than instinct, and an honest view of the trade-off. A higher rent can mean a longer vacancy or a good resident who leaves. A manager who has thought about it is working on your income over years, not the headline rent this month.

  • Listen for: a reason behind the approval limit, judgment about when to call you anyway, a way of catching small problems before they become big ones, and a clear answer on whether the firm makes money on repairs and how you would know.

  • Listen for: inspections that lead to something. Repairs get scheduled, problems get raised with the resident, and there is a record of the home's condition that holds up later. An inspection that ends as a form in a file protects nobody.

  • Listen for: one sequence, followed the same way for every resident. It should start with contact, be built to get the rent paid and keep a good resident, and protect your position if that fails.

  • Listen for: a set schedule, and a statement you can read without calling to have it explained.

  • Listen for: a defined sequence with one person responsible for it. They should be able to say what they are balancing, which is getting the home back on the market quickly against returning it to a standard, and how they decide.

  • Listen for: something specific. A firm that thinks about its work has stopped doing things that did not work, and can tell you what they were.

    • They are specific. You hear how it works, not that they "take it seriously".
    • They name a trade-off. Most decisions in management cost something: speed against care, rent against vacancy, strictness against goodwill. A manager who has thought it through can tell you which way they lean and why.
    • They lead to an outcome for you, and usually for the resident too. Residents who are treated well stay longer and look after the home, and that is where much of an owner's return comes from.
    • They do not depend on one person. You get the same answer whoever you ask, because it is written down and followed.
    • "That is how we have always done it."
    • Promises with no mechanism behind them. "We find great tenants" is not a process.
    • A manager who agrees with everything you suggest. You are hiring judgment, and judgment sometimes says no.

    We have written ours down. How we work and Services explain what we do at each stage and why, and Miles explains why we hold to it in Why we do it the same way every time. Ask us about any of it.

VII   The basics

Check the basics too

These take a few minutes, and no manager should hesitate over any of them.

  • Look the firm up in the Washington Department of Licensing license lookup. It takes a minute. You are trusting someone with an asset worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, and a person who manages other people's property without a license is breaking the law before they start. If the firm is licensed, you do not need to quiz it about how it handles client money: the state audits licensed firms, trust accounts included, and that is a harder test than any answer you would get across a desk. Welcome Home Properties is a licensed real estate firm in Washington.

  • Ask for every fee in writing and work out what it adds up to over a year for your home. Ours are published, and the cost guide shows the arithmetic.

  • Read the management agreement before you sign it, and ask about anything that is unclear. We go through ours with you.

VIII   Asked often

Common questions

  • Contact them the way a renter would and see what happens. It shows you how your future residents, and your vacant home, will be treated.

  • Not by itself. Owners decide how much to invest in a home. Look at what care controls instead: cleanliness, working fixtures and repairs done properly. Then look at how the best homes they manage are kept.

  • Yes. A home listed only on the manager's own site reaches fewer renters. Wider reach brings more qualified applicants, which shortens vacancy and gives the manager a real choice of resident.

  • For each part of the job, ask what they do, why they do it that way, and what result it is meant to produce. Specific, reasoned answers that are the same whoever you ask are a good sign.

Talk to us

Put these questions to us

Call us at (509) 525-1040, Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM, or visit 320 N Colville St, Walla Walla.

Schedule Time with Miles Or request a free rental analysis.